Dumpster Bag vs. Dumpster Rental: Which One is Right for Your Project?

Are you working on a remodeling project or home cleanout, and you’re looking for the best way to get rid of the unwanted junk and debris without making multiple trips to the landfills, if this is you, then pay attention to what I have to share with you. Like most homeowners, you might be caught in the dilemma of whether to buy a dumpster bag, sometimes known as a Bagster bag or rent a temporal dumpster from a local dumpster rental service but don’t know which junk removal option is best for your project. If that is the case, don’t worry, we’ve got you covered!

The waste disposal option to go with depends on two things: the scope of your project and your budget! Having these two important factors in mind will help you choose the right waste disposal option for your project.  Let’s dive in and share all you need to know in other to decide which disposal option is best for your job.

What’s the Difference Between a Dumpster Bag and a Dumpster

Dumpster Bags, also known as Bagster, and Dumpster are both junk removal containers you can place on your property and use to get rid of unwanted materials or debris. Dumpster Bags can be purchased from home improvement stores while dumpsters are rented from a local dumpster service. They serve a similar purpose but differ in some key features such as


The Bagster bag is available in one size only and can hold 3 cubic yard of debris, while dumpsters are available in multiple sizes such as 10, 15, 20, 30, and 40 cubic yard sizes.

Weight Limit

A dumpster bag can hold up to 3,300 pounds of debris, while a dumpster can hold 4,000 to 12,000 pounds of weight based on the cubic yard size.


The Bagster bag is 8 feet long by 4 feet wide by 2.6 feet wide, while the dumpster dimension varies based on their different sizes but they are typically 8 feet wide, 10 – 20 feet long, and 3.5 – 7 feet high.


Bagster bags are made of a tarp-like material with handles and aren’t as durable as a regular dumpster, while a dumpster is made of heavy-duty metal and can load it up with heavy things without having to worry much.


A dumpster bag must be placed within about 18 feet of the street, while a dumpster can be placed in your driveway or parking lot, on your property. You can also place your dumpster in the street but you will need a permit to do that. A permit will allow you to place your dumpster on the street or in another public space.

Pickup and Disposal

Bagster bag collection and disposal are mostly by waste management, while dumpsters are hauled by a local dumpster service.

How Bagster Bag Waste Disposal Work

The idea behind a Bagster Bag is for getting rid of clutter and debris that are too much for your regular trash service and not big enough to require renting a dumpster. Before you go ahead to buy a Bagster at your local home improvement center, you have to ensure that your local hauling company collects them and the permitted debris allow in your area because some debris such as yard waste is not accepted in all areas.

In a nutshell, here’s how Bagster bag process works:

  • Confirm if Bagster pickup is available in your area.
  • Purchase the Bagster from your local home improvement stores or online.
  • Fill your Bagster with debris or waste. The Bagster bag can hold up to 3,300 pounds of debris or waste.
  • When your Bagster bag is full, schedule for pickups from your local hauling company.

How Dumpster Rental Work

A dumpster rental is the perfect cleanup solution for many types of projects and it provides a much more refined process when you’re carrying out a waste disposal project. If you’re wondering how to rent a dumpster, just follow the simple process outlined below.

Here’s how the dumpster rental process work:

  • Choose a reliable dumpster rental company to work with and request a free quote.
  • Schedule your dumpster delivery and prepare for drop-off.
  • Fill the dumpster with your junk or debris.
  • Call for pickup and the dumpster rental company will come and haul your junk away.

Professional dumpster rental companies like Dumpster Stars will work you through the process and answer any questions you have on how dumpster rental works. They will also provide you with the necessary information on how to determine the right size container for your debris and help you during every step of the dumpster rental process from ordering to delivery to pickup.

Dumpster Bag Cost vs. Dumpster Rental Cost

Before we get into the total cost for purchasing a Bagster bag and getting it disposed of, with that of the cost to rent a dumpster, it is important to note that these two waste removal containers differ in sizes, thereby the amount of debris each container can hold depends on its size. A dumpster bag can hold up to 3,300 pounds of debris, while a dumpster can hold 4,000 to 12,000 pounds of debris because of its multiple sizes. The dumpster bag retails as low as $29.95 and the cost of collection varies depending on your location. For a location where the cost of collection for the first bag is $204.75, the total cost will be $235. If you have an additional bag to be collected at the same time, you will likely get a discount on the collection cost for the second bag.

The cost for renting a dumpster varies between $292 and $480 (This number may be higher or slightly lower depending on your location, the size of the dumpster, and the dumpster rental company you work with). A dumpster may look costlier than a dumpster bag but it’s important to note that a 10 yard dumpster, for instance, can hold 3x more debris than a dumpster bag. So if you’re wondering whether to buy a dumpster bag or rent a dumpster, you have to consider the scope of your project and the fact that more debris can be found lying around within the cause of the job, so dumpster rental will be a more affordable and convenient option to go with.

What are the Acceptable Materials that can be Tossed into a Bagster vs. Dumpster?

The materials or debris accepted for both Bagster bag and dumpster are very similar as both containers get dumped in the same local landfills. The main difference in the debris that can be thrown into each container depends on the size of the debris, as well as, the weight limit.

The Bagster Bag is designed to handle small-scale cleanouts or minor home improvement projects with less than 10 cubic yards worth of debris. They are perfect for projects that your normal trash service can’t handle and also don’t require a temporary dumpster.

Here are some of the acceptable materials you can put in a Bagster bag:

Construction Debris, Packaging Materials, Demolition Debris, Roofing, Shingles, Paneling, Siding, Toilets, Windows, Sinks, Plaster, Carpet, Screens, Household Junk, Broken Toys, Bikes, Rugs, Carpets, Lawn Furniture, Old Luggage, Mattresses, Wooden Furniture, Metal Furniture, and Heavy Debris such as Concrete are allowed. Yard waste is not accepted in all areas, so you need to check with your local hauling company to see if it is acceptable in your location.

You can also check with the Bagster bag filling guidelines to determine what is and isn’t accepted in a Bagster.

Renting a dumpster is the perfect cleanup solution for any project with 10 cubic yards of debris or more. Just like the Bagster bag, most non-hazardous waste, junk, and debris are permitted in a dumpster. A dumpster can handle more waste removal projects because of its availability in multiple sizes for both small-scale and large-scale jobs. If you’re not sure if a particular item can be thrown in a dumpster or is prohibited, be sure to check with your local dumpster rental company to ensure you’re not breaking any law.


Knowing the scope of your project, the amount of trash to be disposed and how quickly you want it picked up will help you decide between a Bagster bag or a Bagster alternative like a dumpster rental for your waste disposal project. Dumpster stars provide the best alternative to a Bagster by offering more affordable and convenient dumpster rental services to residents and contractors. If you’re interested in renting a dumpster for your project, reach out to us and a member of our team will help you choose the right size dumpster for your project and answer any questions regarding dumpster rentals of all sizes and time spans.

About Us

Dumpster Stars is your one-stop shop for all your roll-off dumpster needs. Whether you’re looking for a local dumpster rental company to deliver and dispose of your debris, we have the perfect roll-off dumpster rental sizes to handle any job.

Recent Posts

Dumpster Rental Video

Still Have Questions?

If you have any questions concerning dumpster rental that is bordering you, talk to our team and we will provide you with the right answer you need, so that you can find the right container for your project.

or Call 512-567-3235 to get started.